Martin luthers hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in. This new celebration of the unique food of the british isles sees james travel from islands to highlands, cooking and eating everywhere from cornwall to scilly, jersey and guernsey, isle of man to shetland, the peak district, lake district and yorkshire moors, and from wales to skye. Luther famously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw, purportedly because of its lackluster portrayal of the gospel and the ease with which it might be used to foster doctrines of worksrighteousness. Mar 16, 2017 you did remove this statement from all subsequent editions, but i have been unable to find any clear retraction of it, or any evident change in your view later on. Martin luther disliked james, in particular, for its emphasis on works.
Martin luther was born in 1483 in the town of eisleben, germany. In fact, you made more negative statements about jamess letter throughout your life, even as they were mixed at times with measured commendations. It differs from the 1546 roman catholic canon of the council of trent in that it rejects the deuterocanonical books and. A biographer of martin luther promotes faith in the face of. Books by martin luther author of the bondage of the will. The fact of the matter was that there was a canon before luther was born and he was attempting to remove books. In this case the works james was speaking of was merely controlling your tongue. The most dangerous thing luther did christian history. One the most popular quotations from luther is the infamous epistle of straw remark, directed at the canonicity of the book of james. The book is concise and to the point, easy to read and understand for the layman as well as the clergyman. Six points on luthers epistle of straw almost five hundred years after the fact, roman catholics still scrutinize martin luther. In fact, the king james bible of 1611 also incorporated the apocrypha, including the story of susanna, the history of the destruction of bel and the dragon both. If luther waited to remove books, we can presume he would have if he could have. Early in his work as bible lecturer and translator luther expressed doubt as to whether james, hebrews, and revelation are truly apostolic part of the inspired new testament.
He is known for nailing his 95 theses to the door of a catholic church on halloween in 1517. Martin luther wanted to take the book of james out of the bible. His hope was that the church would change some of its practices and doctrines he felt were not right. Im a protestant as ive pointed out many times, and i agree with a lot of luther did, but wasnt it a little disingenuous of him to want to remove the book of james and hebrews because he thought he thought it contradicted his theology. Its written in the style of an academic conference paper and so lacks some pep.
For context, luther, is responding to some of erasmus assertions in support of our natural moral ability to obey the gospel, apart from grace. Jul 14, 2011 for instance, james swans page, luther s view of the canon 2004 attempts to downplay luther s critical prefaces, originally printed before each book in his german bible. If luther had his way, protestants today would be using an incomplete bible of 63 books instead of the incomplete bible of 66 books they do use. Luther s controversial writing concerning the epistle of james and the revelation can be found in volume 35 of luther s works, american edition, pages 395397 and 399400. The edition of 1530 omitted in spirit, thought, and words. This doesnt address the question directly, but is still a nice supplement to the other answer. James does not mention the passion, the resurrection, and the spirit of christ is inane, for his readers knew the apostolic deposit there was no need to mention the very basis and essence of the living faith which was known to those reading the epistle. Luther s canon is the biblical canon attributed to martin luther, which has influenced protestants since the 16thcentury protestant reformation. For instance, james swans page, luthers view of the canon 2004 attempts to downplay luthers critical prefaces, originally printed before each book in his german bible. Luther and the epistle of straw the calvinist international. The book of james is so clear that it even says that your religion is worthless if it does not include the proper works. Dinosaurs and the bible debunking the 7 myths that deny biblical truth series duration. Thats where the foundation of james s call to action is plainest. Martin luther facts, quotes, timeline, 95 theses, reformation.
Jews have never considered those books scripture, and they didnt become officially scripture by the rcc until the council of trent in the 1500s. Its often said that luther was so opposed to the book of james that he. Why did martin luther discard the book of revelation. Six points on luthers epistle of straw james white. Martin luther and the book of james by joe heschmeyer martin luther s hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Did martin luther really want james taken out of the bible. James white a brief history of martin luther and the. In fact, he once offered his doctors cap to anyone who could reconcile it with romans 3. Luther made an attempt to remove the books of hebrews, james, jude and revelation from the canon notably, he perceived them to go against certain protestant doctrines such as sola gratia and sola fide, but this was not generally accepted among his followers.
Although martin luther is better known as a christian reformer and founder of the lutheran church, he was also instrumental in placing greater importance on the role of music in worship and was himself a composer and arranger. No one can understand his theology apart from the history of the black religious experience. He famously described james as an epistle of straw, because it talked about law and good deeds rather than faith, the keystone of luthers. Peters second epistletherefore, although i value this book, it is an epistle that need not be counted among the chief books which are supposed to lay the foundations of faith luther, m. Heres the full context of luthers evaluation from his preface to the new testament. Jun, 20 luther famously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw, purportedly because of its lackluster portrayal of the gospel and the ease with which it might be used to foster doctrines of worksrighteousness. If im not mistaken, martin luther discarded the book of james and revelation in his initial version of the bible. Christians, why did martin luther want to remove the book of. Luther, who would be exiled in the months following the diet of worms council in 1521 that was designed to martyr him, would translate the new testament into german for the first time from the 1516 greeklatin new testament of erasmus, and publish it in september of 1522. The biblical book of james is full of wisdom and is regularly quoted by ministers preaching against gossip the section on taming the tongue in chapter three is powerful stuff. I understand the he discarded james because of the problematic verse james 2. Martin luther, the celebrated catalyst of the protestant reformation, famously took issue with the book of james.
Study james using martin luthers bible commentary to better understand scripture with full outline and verse meaning. To martin luther, james was an epistle of straw that had nothing of the nature of the gospel about it. Luthers controversial writing concerning the epistle of james and the revelation can be found in volume 35 of luthers works, american edition, pages 395397 and 399400. Nestingen was one that i read for work and while i feel like i learned a lot, i dont think it was all that enjoyable. Im a protestant as ive pointed out many times, and i agree with a lot of luther did, but wasnt it a little disingenuous of him to want to remove the book of jamesand hebrews because he thought he thought it contradicted his theology. However, to state my own opinion about it, though without prejudice to anyone, i do not regard. But many people know martin luther s opinion of the book, or think they do, and wonder whether james is really to be placed on the same level as the gospels or pauls letters. I basically felt like i was the object of a barrage of facts. Luther regarded this as opposed to pauls emphasis on faith alone. But many people know martin luthers opinion of the book, or think they do, and wonder whether james is really to be placed on the same level as the gospels or paul. Just in time for the protestant reformations 500th anniversary, eric metaxas biography martin luther hits the hardcover nonfiction list at no. Martin luthers most popular book is the bondage of the will.
While the lutheran confessions specifically did not define a canon, it is widely regarded as the canon of the lutheran church. Feb 29, 2016 your question would be more accurately worded if you asked, why did martin luther remove the 7 books from the catholic bible. Martin luther, the licentiate examination of heinrich schmedenstede, july 7, 1542. Why he said, god resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble. Five hundred years ago, luther reclaimed the gospel from the medieval church, but did he leave the book of james behind. Luthers canon is the biblical canon attributed to martin luther, which has influenced protestants since the 16thcentury protestant reformation. In fact, luther referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw and. In the 16th century, martin luther adopted the jewish list, putting the deuterocanonical books in an appendix. Martin luther was born on november 10 th, 1483, to hans and margaret luther in the small town of eisleben. It may indeed be that luther later tempered some of his views on some books, or that others rightly dropped them from later reprints.
Martin luther and the book of james shameless popery. Nestingen is the author of numerous books, including the faith we hold and editor, with robert kolb, of sources and contexts of the book of concord. Martin luthers understanding of faith departed from the prevailing catholic belief system in many ways. Nestingens book gave me valuable insight on the life of martin luther and the reformation. The james to whom the book is traditionally ascribed is not the brother of john martyred by herod acts 12. Nestingen is professor of church history emeritus at luther seminary in saint paul, minnesota. Martin luther struggled greatly with james not by faith alone jam. He didnt think it expressed the nature of the gospel, it appeared to contradict pauls statements about justification by faith, and it didnt directly mention christ. Luther concluded his preface to james, all of the genuinely sacred books agree in this that all of them preach christ and deal with him. Your question would be more accurately worded if you asked, why did martin luther remove the 7 books from the catholic bible. That said, there is simply not a mechanism for removing anything from the canon in christian circles. Why did martin luther remove 7 books from the bible.
Tomorrow august 28 was to have been the day for officially opening the new and longawaited martin luther king memorial in washington, dc. He is a nationally recognized luther scholar as well as a popular speaker and lecturer. Protestant reformer martin luther cogwriter although protestants like to think positively about martin luther because of his supposed belief in sola scriptura the bible alone, the truth is that martin luther changed parts of the bible and discounted the value of many books notice a change he admitted to regarding romans 3. However, these books are ordered last in the germanlanguage luther bible to this day. Here we see the apostate priest, martin luther, denigrating the book of james because it contradicts his new idea of justification by faith alone. If those who compiled the bible under the direction of the holy spirit made 10 mistakes, or even 7, then we cannot know. Martin luthers description of the epistle of james changes. However, to state my own opinion about it, though without prejudice to anyone, i do not. To luther, the book of james seemed to support the idea that people contributed to their salvation by their good works. Martin luther has 1435 books on goodreads with 61168 ratings. Dec 04, 2017 dinosaurs and the bible debunking the 7 myths that deny biblical truth series duration.
Martin luther king and the king james bible manifold. Luther said james does not mention the passion, the resurrection, or the spirit of christ. His father hans was born to be a farmer and grew up in a farming family, but according to archaic medieval inheritance laws, he was relegated to finding his own fortune and profession in life. Therefore st james epistle is really an epistle of straw, compared to these others, for it has. Here are a couple quotes from him from luther works vol. Now in green are some comments that luther originally made that were in editions of his bible prior to 1530. Jude, no one can deny that it is an extract or copy of st. About this book of the revelation of john, i leave everyone free to hold his own opinions.
Louis scholar release timed with 500th anniversary of the reformation a new book aimed at deepening understanding of the book of concord is now available from one of the most respected reformation scholars of our time. After 1530, the first comments in green were removed. The book of esther and martin luther baptist christian forums. Its often said that luther was so opposed to the book of james that he suggested it didnt belong in the biblical canon. He believed that melody, rhythm and performance of a hymn or chant must be fully in harmony with the texts language. His down to earth descriptions are gems, this is the work of a great mind.
Heres what luther had to say about the book of james. He also put the letter of james, the letter to the hebrews, the letters of john, and the book of revelation from the new testament in an appendix. This view, widely accepted during the middle ages, helped to secure for james a recognized status within the christian canon. He inrich b ornk amm, luthers doctrine of the two kingdoms in the context of his theology, trans. Mar 11, 2015 luther made an attempt to remove the books of hebrews, james, jude and revelation from the canon notably, he perceived them to go against certain protestant doctrines such as sola gratia and sola fide, but this was not generally accepted among his followers. Martin luther changed andor discounted 18 books of the bible. Martin luther, the celebrated catalyst of the protestant reformation, famously took. Luther removed seven entire books from the old testament, and. Perhaps none of martin luthers writings on the bible are as harsh as what he wrote about the revelation of jesus christ revelation 1. He famously described james as an epistle of straw, because it talked about law and good deeds rather than faith, the keystone of luther s theology.
That epistle of james gives us much trouble, for the papists embrace it alone and leave out all the rest. Why was martin luther attempting to change the canon. In some cases, luther argues that it was not written by an apostle. However, a careful look at the context of the book of james reveals that the author is reminding christians that good works flow from saving faith. It may indeed be that luther later tempered some of his views on some books. James epistle is really an epistle of strawfor it has nothing of the nature of the gospel about it luther, m. Aug 27, 2011 martin luther king and the king james bible martin luther king memorial, august 2011. And the key word to come to terms with is word, which appears four times in the passage verses 18, 21, 22, and 23. The second comments in green made by luther were replaced by other comments that are in maroon in the editions after 1530. Martin luther king and the king james bible martin luther king memorial, august 2011.
While the lutheran confessions 1 specifically did not define a canon, it is widely regarded as the canon of the lutheran church. Martin luthers hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Martin luther on the bondage of the will the following quotes come from, what luther considered to be his most important work, the bondage of the will. If those who compiled the bible under the direction of the holy spirit made 10 mistakes, or even 7, then we cannot know with certainty that any book of the bible is divinely inspired. New book released on martin luthers writings by st. Still, luther had concerns about the book of james, as well as the books of. Apr 03, 2007 six points on luthers epistle of straw almost five hundred years after the fact, roman catholics still scrutinize martin luther. You did remove this statement from all subsequent editions, but i have been unable to find any. Why did martin luther remove the 7 books from the bible.
259 1517 1383 1339 1146 248 338 894 1209 1257 466 1321 1423 1068 228 66 111 1439 242 1000 1371 980 750 204 1263 240 1275 1318 303